Best Grill Pan Reviews & Things To Consider Before Purchasing One

Did you ever want to grill great steakhouse steaks? Or, did you want to get those lovely lines on rich meat, fresh fish or green veggies?

Whatever the reason, a grill pan can come handy seriously impressing your kith and kin with your chef skills.

A grill pan is also known as a griddle pan. Basically, a grill pan is a pan that is fashioned with raised edges. These raised edges are formed by grill lines. A grill pan can perfectly substitute your barbecue.

There are several reasons why you should own a grill pan. A steak tastes different with solid parallel grill marks. And, you can only get those chargrilled marks at a restaurant or an outdoor grill. Why go outside when you can cook indoor? 

A grill pan offers a fun and more convenient way to cook your favorite, lavish food indoors. You can choose a grill pan from several different sizes and brands. You may select a heavy-duty cast iron pan or a lighter one.

Below is a list of top 10 grill pans and my experience with them. I checked out how they performed grilling sumptuous steak, hamburgers, and different kinds of vegetables. Moreover, I listed a couple of things to consider before buying a grill pan.

 Best Grill Pan in 2017

1. Vermi Cast Iron Grill Pan — Pre-Seasoned and Durable Cast Iron Skillet

best grill pan
Amazon Logo

Do you like cast-iron cookware?

Are you looking for a skillet that could combine quality design, build and materials in one unit?

When grilling indoors, you have take a multitude of factors into consideration. You can’t afford to purchase a grill pan that is hard to clean and flimsy in construction. You don’t want a skillet that takes the eternity to finish cooking. Most importantly you don’t want a pan that gets food stuck all the time.

So, what grill pan should you buy?

Today, I’m going to introduce one such grill pan that can successfully negate all your trouble you previously faced with a grill pan. And, the grill pan is the Vermi Cast Iron Grill Pan. Let’s find out more about the grill pan:

Who is the Vermi Cast Iron Grill Pan for?

  • This grill pan is designed for any individuals looking to get the most out of a grill pan.
  • If you look for a grill pan according to its practical features, then the Vermi Cast Iron Grill Pan is one of the best on the market.

My Experience with the Vermi Cast Iron Grill Pan

  • Unboxing – I purchased this grill pan this April. I was surprised when I first unboxed the grill pan. The grill pan came packaged in a smooth, modern Amazon box. Therein a nice bubble wrap cushioned the pan. The pans I previously ordered weren’t shipped in such unique packages. I ordered a Lodge grill pan last year from another store, but it wasn’t packaged this nice. I find the silicone handle sleeve really convenient. As you can easily pick it up when hot.
  • Pre-Seasoning – the grill pan is a cast-iron one. And, it comes pre-seasoned. But, from time to time, I have to do my own seasoning. I usually apply olive for seasoning the pan prior to cooking. As you may know, the seasoning gets better with the frequency of cooking.
  • Performance – before using the grill pan for the first time, I coated and pre-seasoned it with some olive oil. Then, I started heating it upside down in the oven for half an hour. After heating it, I left it for the night. The next day, I used the grill pan to brown ground beef for tacos.

As I started cooking, I noticed a few spots where the ground beef got stuck. The next time, when I spilled olive oil on to those spots, nothing ever got stuck to its surface. I usually prepare chicken breasts, fresh fish and a variety of veggies on the grill pan. And, they come out great.

What I like

  • Comes pre-seasoned
  • Well-constructed and durable
  • Plenty of cooking space
  • Silicone handle sleeve

What I don’t like

  • Doesn’t come with a lid

FAQs

Q: What kind of stovetop is the grill best suited for?

A: The Vermi Cast Iron Grill Pan works better on a gas stovetop.

Q: How much does the grill pan weigh?

A: The grill pan weighs in at about 7 lbs.

Q: Can I use the grill pan in the microwave?

A: No, you can’t.

You may also like: Best Grill Pan for Gas Stove

Final Verdict

If you’re looking for a high-quality grill pan to sear steaks and veggies to perfection, then the Vermi Cast Iron Grill Pan should be a top choice. It features durable construction, plenty of cooking and comes pre-seasoned.

If you want to learn more about the Vermi Cast Iron Grill Pan, visit Amazon for more reviews!

 

2. Rachael Ray Cucina Hard-Anodized Nonstick 11-Inch Deep Square Grill Pan 

Hard Anodized Nonstick 11 Inch Deep Square Grill Pan

Hard Anodized Nonstick Deep Grill Pan

Amazon Logo

Rachael Ray Cucina featuring a lifetime limited warranty, this grill pan boasts of 4.8 out of 5 stars on Amazon. I absolutely love this pan.

Previously I owned a pan made of aluminum. It was inefficient in cooking on medium high heat. But, this pan is made of anodized aluminum, which allows fast and even heating. It comes with a nonstick interior and incredibly deep sides. It distributes heat evenly with ridges that leave appealing sear marks on your steak. The ridges lock in the flavor efficiently while allowing the fat to drip out of the meat.

It measures 11 inches and has 2-inch sides, which allow you to grill a perfect steakhouse chop or steak. I sometimes use it in the oven for improved flavor, reaching the heat of up to 400 degrees. The pan is also simpler clean, thanks to PFOA-free, espresso-colored nonstick material.

The previous pan I had was tough to clean. It is also equipped with a durable stay-cool handle, which makes clean-up even easier. The pan proved effective at cooking fish too. I caught a king (chinook) salmon last September. And, I used this pan to cook it. It stuck in the grill pan since it is so delicate.

What I like

  • Nonstick finish
  • Browned steak evenly
  • Stay-cool handle and lid
  • Safe up to 400°F in the oven
  • Exterior remained clean after use
  • Efficient at distributing heat evenly

What I don’t like

  • Riveted handles kinda makes it harder to clean

Rachael Ray Cucina Hard-Anodized Nonstick 11-Inch Deep Square Grill Pan is awarded 4.8 out 5 stars on Amazon. Check out the reviews.

3. Calphalon Contemporary Nonstick 11-Inch Square Grill Pan

Calphalon contemporary nonstick 11 inch square grill pan

Calphalon contemporary nonstick grill pan

Amazon Logo

You know what the pros are having a heavy-duty aluminum construction?

It provides equal heat distribution for superior cooking. The Calphalon is a heavy-duty model.

The biggest benefit of owning this pan is that it is made of anodized aluminum with a nonstick interior. Its interior features three layers of nonstick coating. Two of those three layers add durability and the third ensures a quick clean-up.

It heats quicker than cast iron. And, another advantage of having anodized aluminum is that it is much lighter than cast iron. The pan’s ridges are stamped, as a result, they allow for fat separation. The deep ridges provide genuine grill flavor and low-fat cooking. Plus, it is much easier to clean up after use.

It took me less than a minute to hand-wash it. I cooked salmon, shrimp, pork chop, lamb chop. And, I was left in awe because it kept them evenly cooked, savory, tender and juicy. It completely changed my cooking experience and simplified cooking my cooking process.

What I like

  • Lightweight
  • Browned meat well
  • Distributes heat evenly
  • Three layers of nonstick coating
  • Oven safe for better cooking efficiency

What I don’t like

  • Ridges are not that deep
  • Fatty foods sometimes end up soaking in oil instead of being raised above it

Calphalon Contemporary Nonstick 11-Inch Square Grill Pan received an excellent rating from online buyers. It generated over 400 customer reviews at 4.7 out 5 stars on Amazon. Check them out

4. Anolon Advanced Hard-Anodized Nonstick 11-Inch Deep Square Grill Pan

Anolon advanced hard anodized nonstick 11 inch deep square grill panAmazon Logo

Well, what’s not to like about this pan?

Added this to Anolon Hard-Anodized item collection. I always watched cooking programs on TV where chefs use a pan and oven to do steaks over a gas burner.

I ended up buying a gas range and started doing steaks like them. And, this pan proved highly effective so far. I just need to fit this on my gas burner and light it up on high.

And, it is hot enough to sear chicken, salmons and leave beautiful grill marks on them within a few minutes. After being done with preparing my meal, there comes the irritating cleaning up the task. But, the pan was able to cut down on my cleaning-up task.

Just take it to your sink, simply soak and rinse it out with hot soapy water and maybe sweep it with a stiff nylon brush and you’re done! I bought this pan on a whim. Now I’m in awe at how efficient it actually is.

What I like

  • Fully nonstick
  • Easier to clean-up
  • Dual-riveted handle
  • Comfortable to grasp and handle

What I don’t like

  • A bit heavy

Anolon Advanced Hard-Anodized Nonstick 11-Inch Deep Square Grill Pan has achieved 4.7 out 5 stars on Amazon. Check out the reviews and specs on Amazon

5. Calphalon Unison Nonstick 12-Inch Round Grill Pan

calphalon unison nonstick 12 inch round grill pan

Calphalon unison nonstick 12 inch round grill pan

Amazon Logo

This circular grill pan features a larger panel. This larger panel offers you plenty of space to cook your favorite food items in a matter of minutes.

I cooked a couple of pork steaks on medium high heat on the Fourth of July. And, the results are satisfying. Everyone present admired my cooking skills and described how tender, mouth-watering the steaks tasted. Really, thanks to this pan. It comes with a clear glass kit that allows you to check your cooking progress.

Its 2 non-stick surfaces prevent food from getting stuck on the ridges. I have done a few onions, chicken cutlets, burgers, pork chops and overall it performed great. It prepares the best burgers ever. The pan delivers the fantastic grill marks that you crave for. It is also dishwasher-safe, therefore you can clean it up in a breeze.

What I like

  • Easy to handle
  • 2 nonstick surfaces
  • Incredibly ultra-smooth side pans
  • Stay-cool, quadruple-riveted handles

What I don’t like

  • Ridges aren’t quite deep

Calphalon Unison Nonstick 12-Inch Round Grill Pan has generated over 270 customer reviews at 4.6 out 5 stars on Amazon. Check them out

6. Starfrit Die-Cast Aluminum Nonstick 10-Inch Square Grill Pan

Starfrit die cast aluminum nonstick 10 inch square grill pan

Starfrit die cast aluminum nonstick grill pan

Amazon Logo

I have used this pan for a couple of times and it completely won me over. The pan takes a while to get hot. Since it’s a bit large, it’s designed to take some time. Once it gets hot, it’s able to retain heat efficiently, even when you drop a cold steak on its surface.

Its handle is foldable, which is good for easy storage. And, the handle has a locking mechanism that keeps it secure in place. It is lightweight and a very convenient grill pan. I normally use it for making French Bread, hot sandwiches and frying beef chop. It is extremely easy to use.

All I have to do is pour a small amount of olive oil on the grill, then allow it to heat up, then slap some chops on its surfaces. Its surface is scratch-resistant, and nonstick, which provides superior durability and effortless food release. It is also simpler to clean it up. Just soak it in soapy water, give it a couple of swipes, rinse it with clean water and you’re done!

What I like

  • Lightweight
  • Foldable handle
  • Super space-saver
  • Quick and easy to clean up
  • Scratch-resistant nonstick surface

Starfrit Die-Cast Aluminum Nonstick 10-Inch Square Grill Pan is awarded 4.6 out 5 stars on Amazon. Check out the reviews and specs on Amazon

7. Happycall 5-Layer Diamond Nonstick Grill Frying Pan, 11-Inch Grill Pan

happycall 5 layer diamond nonstick grill frying pan 11 inch grill pan

Happycall 5 layer diamond frying grill pan

Amazon Logo

My wife recommended that I buy this pan. And, I ended up purchasing it. It has been working as fine as it was advertised. It surrounds steak and fresh with a savory crisp.

It cooks meat, fish and green vegetables inside out. It does eggs well. So, if you love omelets, you’ll love this pan. It equally distributes heat, therefore you can rest assured that your scrambled eggs are being cooked to perfection. My family had many nonstick, and this one is the best yet.

This pan is much easier to clean up as it has a nonstick scratch-resistant surface. Nothing gets stuck when cooking. It is as easy as wiping the pan with a paper towel, then rinsing and wipe-drying. Like all nonstick coatings, this pan contains PTFE.

Plus, HappyCall avoided using the chemical PFOA in the nonstick coating process. As a result, it is PFOA-free. PFOA is considered a pollutant. Overall, it is an excellent grill pan that gives you more bang for your buck.

What I like

  • Lightweight
  • Easy cleaning
  • Durable and PFOA-free

Happycall 5-Layer Diamond Nonstick Grill Frying Pan, 11-Inch Grill Pan has received 4.7 out of 5 stars on Amazon. Check out the reviews.   

8. Lodge L8SGP3 Cast Iron Square Grill Pan, Pre-Seasoned

lodge l8sgp3 cast iron square grill pan pre seasoned

Lodge l8sgp3 cast iron square grill pan

Amazon Logo

Tired of spending on eating out? Here’s a grill pan that took the grill pan-industry by storm. My friend recommended this pan to me and I’m so glad that she did.

This grill pan is really a real bargain at less than $20. I first cooked a couple of chicken breasts without bones using this grill. Boy, didn’t they taste good? The pan is thick and robust. Since it’s made of cast iron, it’s bound to be heavy. Its weight is nearly 10 lbs.

It retains heat efficiently due to its cast iron construction. Did I tell you the pan comes pre-seasoned? If you have the tentative patience for making your favorite foods, the grill is ready to use. If you follow the low-fat diet, it’s ideal for you. Its ribbed bottom allows you to keep food from charring in fatty drippings for low-fat cooking.

What I like

  • Comes pre-seasoned
  • Effective for low-fat cooking
  • Superior heat retention ability

What I don’t like

  • A bit heavy
  • Produces smoke when grilling

Lodge L8SGP3 Cast Iron Square Grill Pan, Pre-Seasoned has generated over 2600 customer reviews at 4.4 out of 5 stars on Amazon. Check them out

9. MAKER Homeware Rectangular Steam Grill Pan

Maker homeware rectangular steam grill pan

maker homeware rectangular steam grill pan

Amazon Logo

I have been fascinated with the idea of a nonstick grill pan for a while. The previous grill pan I had was a large George Foreman. But, I was not quite satisfied with it. So, I began browsing through online stores with the objective of buying one that could add value, functionality, and usability.

I came across this great pan manufactured by IRIS USA, it is MAKER Rectangular Grill Pan. I have been using it for like a year. And, it proved extremely effective for grilling beef steak, pork chop, hot sandwiches, sausages, etc.

It leaves those fantastic grill marks, and you won’t have to light up the BBQ during the winter. It can cook perfectly on medium high heat. I used a lower heat with the lid to prepare some asparagus and squash. And, it turned out well.

Cleaning up process seemed easier than the George Foreman I used. I just soaked it in soapy water, then used a sponge to wash it and everything looked neat and clean within a minute. The grill pan comes with a coating, so never use on high heat. Plus, do not use metal utensils or leave the food in the pan long after you finish cooking. These practices will damage the coating.

What I like

  • Steam cooking; it prevents creating smoke when cooking
  • Gets very hot within a short period
  • Spacious grilling surface
  • Food doesn’t stick
  • Dishwasher-safe

What I don’t like

  • Lid doesn’t handle oven temps over 350°F
  • No extended handle

MAKER Homeware Rectangular Steam Grill Pan is awarded 4.5 out 5 stars on Amazon. Check out more reviews on Amazon

10. Gibson Home 62412.01 Hummington 11-Inch Ceramic Nonstick Square Grill Pan

Gibson home 62412 01 hummington 11 inch ceramic nonstick square grill pan

Gibson home 62412 01 hummington square grill pan

Amazon Logo

This is really a multi-function pan I used. It takes less cooking time and pretty easy to clean. I was able to make delicious steamed fish, chicken and potatoes.

I absolutely love its ceramic breed of non-stick, so does my eco-friendly spouse who prefers the PFOA-free nonstick coating. And, this pan comes with such coating. It comes with a dark green ceramic nonstick surface. I have cooked omelets in several times.

And, there was hardly any sticking. I just poured a little olive oil first. If food does stick to it, then apply vinegar/baking soda method. Just mix vinegar with baking soda and water. Apply the solution to the burned or stained area. The solution will bubble up. Once the bubbles disappear, heat up the grill pan. Heat it up for at least 15 minutes. Let it sit there until you need it anytime soon.

The surface appeared a little thin to me at first, but it didn’t affect the pan’s overall performance. It is much simpler to clean actually. I was just able to wipe it out with a paper towel. It’s grilling surface is rather large (11-inch). It could easily fit 4-5 burger patties at once.      

What I like

  • Large grilling surface
  • Very well-made and durable
  • Dishwasher-safe, stay-cool handle

What I don’t like

  • Food sometimes stick to it

Gibson Home 62412.01 Hummington 11-Inch Ceramic Nonstick Square Grill Pan has achieved 4.1 out of 5 stars on Amazon. Check out over 400 reviews for the product on Amazon

11. Weber Style 6435 Professional-Grade Grill Pan 

Weber style 6435 professional grade grill pan

Weber style 6435 professional grade grill pan

Amazon Logo

This is surely one of the best grill pans on the market. I was compelled to buy this pan as it received top ratings from America’s Test Kitchen.

I have used multiple different grill pans in the past. I wasn’t quite satisfied with them because they seemed to coincide with one common issue, which is welds. Instead of being stamped or folded, most pans are usually welded. As a result, the welds tend to break due to the high heat of the grill.

But, this pan is composed of one piece and it contains no welds. It’s excellent size 13.5″ X 18.5″ with raised edges will give you the upper hand in flipping and turning food. Plus, raised edges to ensure everything remains in the pan. It is great for veggies. The bottom of the grill pan contains small openings that brown the veggies. It is made of high-grade stainless steel, thus it retains heat well and is much easier to clean.    

It did an ace job of grilling chicken breasts, hamburgers and veggies like asparagus and shishito peppers. Plus, it was really easy for me to clean afterward.

What I like

  • Good size
  • Raised edges
  • Great for grilling fish
  • Robust stainless steel

What I don’t like

  • Smaller foods like onion slices fall through the grill

Weber Style 6435 Professional-Grade Grill Pan has generated over 620 customer reviews at 4.4 out of 5 stars on Amazon. Check them out

Things to Consider before Purchasing a Grill Pan

⊕ Non-stick ability- some food items have a nasty tendency of latching onto pans like a limpet. So, it is important that you apply onto your ingredients to avoid them getting stuck to your pan. Some grill pans have nonsticking coatings and others don’t. Some grill pans do have better nonstick coatings. So, make sure your pan has this coating. Regardless of your pan’s feature, it is good to oil your food items.

⊕ Grade of Ridge –This is what most of us purchased a grill pan for — to get the beautiful grill mark finish on our food. There are several different qualities of ridges and grill lines can be found offered by different brands. The best grill pans I listed above can deliver fantastic grill marks on your food. However, to get the perfect striped finish on your steak, high and sharply defined ridges deliver better grill lines than dull and rounded ridges.

⊕ Drainage – look for a pan with additional drainage channels. Sloped sides or moats can catch the juices from cooking.

⊕ Weight – grill pans come in a variety of weights. Some can be a lot heavier than others. And, some can be a bit lighter. You need enough wrist strength to carry around super-heavy grill pans. Lightweight versions of grill pans can be as effective as heftier ones.

Calphalon Contemporary Grill Pan, that is described above, can be lightweight, but totally effective. The weight of a grill pan is correlated to conduction and retention. So, strike a balance among them.

⊕ Heat Conduction – heat transfer refers to an exchange of thermal energy between two objects. Heat conduction is one type of heat transfer. Conducting cooking processes heat transfer between objects upon direct contact. Heat conduction produces an exterior that is evenly cooked and an interior that is juicy and moist.

A steak that consists of both of these sections can sure impress your guest. So, how can a grill pan deliver such qualities? To attain such quality, look for a pan that heats up pretty quickly.

⊕ Heat Retention – heat retention refers to the ability to retain heat when cooking. Heat retention helps cook evenly. So, look for a grill pan with better heat retention ability.

⊕ Body – cast iron, stainless steel, anodized aluminum; grill pans come in different types of body. Cast iron does an excellent job at retaining heat at high temps. It is referred to as an ideal material for a grill pan. Stainless steel or anodized aluminum produces a lightweight pan. Either of these types has higher heat conduction ability. But, they don’t retain heat that well.

⊕ Surface – your pan’s surface is where you’ll cook. So, it has to be high-quality and PFOA- and PTFE-free. Cooking surfaces can come either pre-seasoned or coated with enamel. The seasoned interior tends to last longer.

You can re-season to increase patina as well. Surfaces that come coated with enamel are easier to clean. A stainless grill pan is usually difficult to clean. If you do want to buy a stainless or aluminum grill pan, look for one with easy-to-clean nonstick coating feature.

 

Pros & Cons of a Grill Pan — Is It Worth Buying?

best grill pan

Are you short of space and living in an apartment?

Do you want to prepare delicious and fantastic steak dishes indoors?

Summer is knocking at the door. When everyone will be outside grilling, having the whiff of crusty, savory pork chops is not enough. But, most apartment dwellers don’t have outside space or can’t fire up the grill without janitors knocking on the door.

So, should you just make reservations at a fancy restaurant?

No, with a stovetop grill pan, you can also prepare crusty, tasty meat, fresh fish, and veggies.

What about the char-grill marks?

Yes, you can also achieve them with a stovetop grill pan. Although a grill pan may not recreate the flavor of the flame, you can prepare delicious grilled sandwiches, burgers, and crispy steaks. In this article, I explored the reasons why you should buy a grill pan and what you stand to lose with a grill pan. Let’s find out about them:

Pros

  • Grill Marks an effective grill pan leaves tasty char-grill marks on steak, veggies or fish. Food usually develops little black dents that you’re used to seeing in steakhouses.
  • Ample Cooking Area a normal grill pan can prepare five hamburgers at the same time. If you purchase a grill pan with wide dimensions, you can prepare chicken breasts, veggies or kebabs at the same time! Many grill pans fit over two burners. Therefore, you’ll get a lot of surface area.
  • Reversible Grill Pan a reversible grill pan can flip over and you can use it as a griddle. As a result, you can make pancakes. Also, bacon lovers will find a reversible pan useful.
  • Ridges – love seeing fat dripping between the grates of a grill? A grill pan has ridges that allow fat and oil to flow off the meat.
  • Equal Heating – most grill pans distribute heat evenly across the cooking surface, thus cooking food to perfection.

Cons

  • No Outdoorsay Flavor – an indoor grill pan can’t replicate the flavor of an outdoor grill pan. Since there are no charcoal or wood chips to be used as a fuel.
  • Can Produce Smoke A Lot – cooking a large quantity of meat indoors is a big no-no. Since you will have to cook them over high temperatures, grill pans are likely to produce a lot of smoke.
  • No Smokey Flavor – since indoor grill use no charcoal or wood chips, they hardly produce smoke. Smoke produced by an outdoor grill can get infused into the food and create smokey flavors.
  • Cooking Outdoors Is More Fun – when the outside weather is decent and you like the outdoors, there’s nothing like relaxing outdoor with a can of beer and tending the grill.
  • Different Heat Distribution – when barbecuing outdoors, your food receives heat from charcoal or wood chips. This is really useful for cooking quickly and evenly.

Bottom Line – grill pans have their fair share of pros and cons. Sure a grill pan can produce flavor of an outdoor grill. But, it comes with immense benefits. You don’t have to go to a fancy restaurant or set up a grill outside to relish in your favorite food. An indoor grill can help you whip up luxurious dishes right in your kitchen!

      Shares